My Google Page Rank

PAL seeks reversal of DOLE ruling on FASAP case

PDFPrintE-mail

 

Philippine Airlines (PAL) is seeking reversal of a labor department ruling granting hefty back salary increases and higher retirement age for flights attendants.

In a press briefing on January 10, 2011, PAL president and COO Jaime J. Bautista said that apart from lack of legal and factual basis, the ruling of the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) is “confiscatory” as it obliges the flag carrier to share income it did not earn.

In a motion for reconsideration filed by its lawyers Friday, Bautista said DOLE’s order raising the flight attendants’ retirement age to 60 years old has no justification in law and jurisprudence and goes against industry practice worldwide.

DOLE’s Dec. 23, 2010 ruling favored the Flight Attendants and Stewards Association of the Philippines (FASAP) by granting back salary increases amounting to P222 million, a higher compulsory retirement age at 60 years old, and increased monthly rice allowance of P1,800, among others.

In particular, PAL wants DOLE to:

·        reconsider and reinstate PAL’s lump-sum offer of P80 million to FASAP members considering its financial status for the periods subject of the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) negotiations;

·        maintain the retirement age at 45 years old instead of 60 while eliminating any distinction between domestic and international flight attendants for flight assignments; and

·        peg the monthly rice allowance for 2007-2008 of FASAP members at P1,200 until Sept. 30, 2007; P1,500 between Oct. 1, 2007 to Sept. 30, 2008; and P1,800 from October 1, 2008.

PAL said DOLE’s wanton disregard of the evidence and rules of fair play is a violation of its duty to render a decision based on fact and law.

Bautista explained that the subject of the labor dispute is the deadlock in the CBA negotiations between PAL and FASAP from the period July 16, 2007 to July 15, 2010, but the DOLE based its economic awards to FASAP on PAL’s purported financial statements for fiscal year 2010-2011, specifically covering only the months of April, May and June 2010.

“These financial statements cannot subvert or supplant the fact that PAL incurred losses. In essence, DOLE is directing PAL to grant hefty pay increases for July 2007 to July 2010 despite its knowledge and awareness of PAL’s massive losses for the same period,” Bautista stressed.

He lamented that it is unjust and even confiscatory to oblige PAL to share income it did not even earn or does not have. “DOLE expects PAL to produce the money but as to how, the decision did not say,” Bautista said.

He said PAL could only infer that the DOLE is probably of the view that future income of the company from April 2010 forward can be applied to the salary increases it granted to FASAP for July 2007-2008, July 2008-2009, and July 2009-2010.

“But this will result in an absurd situation. It is an unthinkable fiscal maneuvering. Considering that the DOLE had already ‘pledged’ any income of PAL for the next years, one can only wonder where PAL is supposed to source funds for the succeeding demands for salary increase when negotiations for the 2010-2015 PAL-FASAP CBA begin,” Bautista said, quoting a portion of PAL’s motion for reconsideration.

To prove its point, PAL presented pertinent records to DOLE showing that it suffered losses of US$297.8 million in fiscal year 2008-2009, and US$14.3 million for fiscal year ending March 2010.

On the retirement age issue, Bautista said DOLE should not have ignored the fact that the memorandum of agreements (MOAs) between the company and FASAP that provided lower retirement age were the product of voluntary negotiations within the framework of their previous CBA.

He said Article 287 of the Labor Code, as amended by Republic Act 7641, states that any person may be retired upon reaching the retirement age established in the collective bargaining agreement or other applicable employment contract. “Thus, a careful reading of the above provision indicates that employers and employees are at liberty to agree and fix the applicable retirement age even at below 60 years old.”

“Besides,” Bautista said, “DOLE failed to consider the fact that the average retirement age of most, if not all, of PAL’s fiercest competitors in the ASEAN region is much less than 60 years old. Thus, early retirement for flight attendants is fast becoming the rule rather than the exception.”

He also chided DOLE for accepting FASAP’s argument that since the 2005-2010 CBA containing the agreed retirement age had already expired then there is no more agreed retirement age to invoke. “We can’t understand how DOLE and FASAP can legally justify that only the retirement provisions of the PAL-FASAP CBA have expired while other provisions on salaries, perks and work rules remain valid and in effect,” he said.

Even the absence of an agreement, Bautista said, does not warrant the outright rejection of PAL’s position (PAL) without taking into account the bargaining history between the parties. He said PAL did not force FASAP officers and members to accept the early retirement provisions as these were subject of negotiations and were approved and ratified by FASAP members in exchange for numerous concessions, in the form of monetary benefits, easier work rules and other perks. remain valid and in effect,” he said.

 




Related news items:
Newer news items:
Older news items:

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Globe myBusiness gives tips to working in the comfort of your own home

23 Mar 2017 Hits:36 Be the first to comment!

Many business owners enjoy working from home, but there’s a challenge that automatically comes with it.  There are certainly many perks, like being in charge of your own time, dressing however you want and being able to take care of personal tasks even as you manage your business.  But while all this is enjoyable, there’s undoubtedly a wide range of distractions at home that can keep you from being as productive as you want to be – and in business, being unproductive is a huge setback. As a work-from-home business owner, then, you need a strategy to stay focused.  Check out these tips to keep you concentrated on what you have to do: - Define your workspace.  When you’re in an office, [...] Read more

Prev Next Page:

Cocolisap funds await PCA, City Hall coordination gab

22 Mar 2017 Hits:54 Be the first to comment!

Funds to rehabilitate the coconut industry following the cocolisap devastation cannot be released as of yet until after the Philippine Coconut Authority (PCA) regional office 9 and the city government [...] Read more


Koko sees okay of free internet access, six key bills this year

22 Mar 2017 Hits:79 Be the first to comment!

Senate President Aquilino “Koko” Pimentel III said Congress is expected to approve this year the bill on free internet access in all public places and six other key priority measures [...] Read more


Ateneo shines anew in Physician Licensure Exam

22 Mar 2017 Hits:74 Be the first to comment!

The Ateneo de Zamboanga University School of Medicine (ADZU-SOM) once again came up with an impressive performance during the recent Physician Licensure Examination (PLE) given by the Board of Medicine [...] Read more


Globe At Home Customers Meet the Cast of Wicked

21 Mar 2017 Hits:65 Be the first to comment!

The year is just beginning, but one of the highlights of 2017 is the staging of the Wicked, the West End musical, which transformed the Theatre at Solaire into the [...] Read more


Zambo harvests 80 gold medals in ZPRAA

21 Mar 2017 Hits:81 Be the first to comment!

The Zamboanga delegation ranked second in the secondary level and third in the elementary level in the recently concluded Zamboanga Peninsula Regional Athletic Association (ZPRAA) meet held in Dipolog City [...] Read more


Lamitan in state of calamity

18 Mar 2017 Hits:131 Be the first to comment!

The city council of Lamitan, last Wednesday, declared a state of calamity in the entire city. Vice Mayor Roderick Furigay said, the City Council concurred with the request of the barangay [...] Read more


Double barrel reloaded nets four more

18 Mar 2017 Hits:121 Be the first to comment!

Four more suspected drug pushers were arrested in another Project Double Barrel-Reloaded operation in Zamboanga City, last Thursday. Arrested were Gilbert Johnston y Dagoy, 48, single, of Sitio Lantawan, Barangay Pasonanca; [...] Read more


SSS releases March differential of P1,000 additional benefit

17 Mar 2017 Hits:115 Be the first to comment!

The state-run Social Security System on Thursday said it has already released about P2.1 billion to its partner banks for the release of the last tranche of the retroactive P1,000 [...] Read more


Aboitiz, DTI partner anew for Matigsalug livelihood project

16 Mar 2017 Hits:109 Be the first to comment!

AboitizPower subsidiary Therma South, Inc. (TSI) in partnership with Aboitiz Foundation, Inc. (AFI), has tied up with the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) 11 to implement a comprehensive crafts [...] Read more


6th InfoCar meets with 100 IDPs

16 Mar 2017 Hits:97 Be the first to comment!

Some 100 internally displaced persons (IDPs) met with local and government agencies for a half-day engagement to discuss the progress and developments of the City’s rehabilitation and recovery efforts. Spearheaded by [...] Read more


Forwarding company robbed

15 Mar 2017 Hits:115 Be the first to comment!

The office of a forwarder company was robbed by unidentified burglars who carted away computer accessories, bank checks and cash. Police Station 11 report showed that the officer-in-charge of the Overseas [...] Read more


PAGASA forecasts late El Niño

14 Mar 2017 Hits:147 Be the first to comment!

The Philippine Atmospheric Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) forecasts the probability of El Niño in the country sometime in the later quarters of 2017. Chief Meteorological Officer Maribel G. Enriquez [...] Read more


NGCP launches program for aspiring transmission line personnel

14 Mar 2017 Hits:110 Be the first to comment!

System operator and transmission service provider, NGCP, formally introduces the Line Ranger School, a program that seeks young individuals who want to become the new generation of transmission line experts. During [...] Read more


NGCP to continue massive facility improvements in 2017

13 Mar 2017 Hits:110 Be the first to comment!

In its continuing pursuit of upgrading and strengthening the country’s power transmission network, NGCP is poised to undertake several major facility improvement programs this year. “When we took over, it was [...] Read more


Beng commits to Duterte’s order to use powers toward peace

13 Mar 2017 Hits:148 Be the first to comment!

Mayor Beng Climaco has strongly committed to implement President Rodrigo Duterte’s directive for mayors and governors to fully exercise their powers and supervision over the police and help him maintain [...] Read more


Presidential Communications Office shiftsa to 2nd gear - Andanar

12 Mar 2017 Hits:138 Be the first to comment!

Presidential Communications Secretary Martin Andanar on Thursday, announced “revitalizing” changes to be made to his office this week during a meeting with the Kapisanan ng mga Broadcasters ng Pilipinas (KBP). The [...] Read more


Job Fair hires 74 on the spot

11 Mar 2017 Hits:144 Be the first to comment!

Despite the inclement weather condition yesterday, job seekers trooped to the Red Cross Training Center in Pettit Barracks for the day-long Job Fair facilitated by the Public Employment Service Office [...] Read more


Three more nabbed for illegal drugs

11 Mar 2017 Hits:158 Be the first to comment!

Three more suspected drug pushers were arrested in the continuous anti-illegal drugs operations of the different police stations in the city. Police Station 7 Drugs Enforcement Team arrested Eric Bejerano y [...] Read more