My Google Page Rank

House prosecution panel replies to impeachment raps vs SC chief justice


The impeachment prosecution panel of the House of Representatives on Monday filed its reply to the Senate who sits as the impeachment court, to Supreme Court (SC) Chief Justice Renato Corona’s answer to the impeachment complaint.

Chief prosecutor Iloilo Rep. Niel Tupas said their reply "entirely debunks all of the defenses raised by Chief Justice Corona in his answer (dated Dec. 21, 2011)."

With the submission of their reply, Tupas said they were more confident that the Senate would be convinced of the strength of the case against the chief justice.

The 38-page Reply sought for the immediate denial of Corona’s prayer for the dismissal of the complaint; that the trial proceed immediately; and to convict the Chief Justice for betrayal of public trust.

Among the salient points raised was that the impeachment "is not an attack on the Judiciary and does not seek to threaten its independence."

On the contrary, it said the impeachment "aims to restore the independence of the Judiciary by freeing it from the clutches of influence of GMA (Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo), former FG (First Gentleman) Mike Arroyo and their cabal. It will not weaken the judiciary but strengthen it. What the impeachment seeks to do is to restore the people’s faith of the independence of the SC which was sorely lost with the string of decisions made by CJ Corona to protect GMA. Most significant was the issuance of an ex parte TRO (temporary restraining order) that would have allowed GMA to go scot-free."

It further said that the impeachment did not violate the Rule of Law.

In fact, it said the complaint "seeks to strengthen it by showing to the people that, contrary to Corona’s contention, any person, even a Chief Justice is not above the law. When a public officer betrays the public trust, he must be brought to justice and held accountable, even if it’s the Chief Justice that is accused. Only then will people believe that there really is the rule of law in our country."

The congressmen-prosecutors also said in their reply that there was no factual basis on Corona’s claim that President Benigno Aquino III wanted to appoint his own Chief Justice, which will be at his beck and call.

"Firstly, this argument only betrays his (Corona) deepest secret: that he is beholden to the person who appointed him -- GMA. Secondly, if that were the objective of PNoy, it should be noted that the three appointees of PNoy voted against the Hacienda Luisita issue. This completely belies Corona’s contention," it said.

They also said that non-disclosure of its statement of assets and liabilities networth (SALN) was a blatant disregard by the Chief Justice on the policy of transparency, public accountability, and the public’s constitutional right to information.

"Section 17, Article XI of 1987 Constitution requires all public officers and employees to file and make available their SALN for inspection and copying by the public. The law makes no exception. For Corona to shield himself from this constitutional measure on transparency using an internal Supreme Court guideline, smacks of a blatant violation of clear requirements stated by law," they said.

"The Chief Justice should not hide behind technicalities. The people want the truth to come out. He has been saying that he has a powerhouse team and that he has been eagerly waiting to present his evidence. The prosecution is likewise ready. Let's get it on for the sake of the people," said Tupas.

Meanwhile, the Iloilo solon said the last slot of the 11-man prosecution panel will be occupied by a lady prosecutor.

"We will not disclose the congresswoman's identity at the moment until her election is made on the plenary floor on Jan. 16," he said.

On the other hand, House Deputy Speaker and Quezon Rep. Lorenzo "Erin" Tanada III withdrew from the prosecution panel to be part of the pool of speakers.

Tanada will join Reps. Federico Miro Quimbo (Marikina) and Juan Edgardo Angara (Aurora), who were earlier tapped to be the deputy spokespersons of the panel.

His slot in the prosecution panel will be taken by alternate prosecutor Cibac party-list Rep. Sherwin Tugna.

Tanada expressed confidence the prosecution team will get the 16 votes needed to impeach the Chief Justice.

By Lilybeth G. Ison

Related news items:
Newer news items:
Older news items:

Add comment

Security code

Beng welcomes Litlit’s appointment as SP member

15 Feb 2018 Hits:153 Be the first to comment!

President Rodrigo Duterte has appointed San Roque Barangay Chairman Joselito “Litlit” Macrohom as member of the Sangguniang Panlungsod or City council replacing Charlie Mariano who stepped down from office last November 2017. As this developed, Mayor Beng Climaco congratulated Macrohon on his appointment and wished him luck in all his endeavors. With the complete set of councilors for both Districts I and II and the sectoral representatives, the Sangguniang Panlungsod can maximize its potentials and come up with quality legislations that are in line with the priority thrust of the local government on Security Health and Education, the mayor said. Macrohon ran for Councilor under District I during the May 2016 local elections and landed 9th place. Macrohon’s appointment, along with other new appointments [...] Read more

Prev Next Page:

City Registrar observes Civil Reg Month

15 Feb 2018 Hits:79 Be the first to comment!

The city, through the Office of the City Civil Registrar,is observing the Civil Registration Month this February with several activities highlighting the importance of civil registration. The month-long observance is punctuated [...] Read more

CHO stresses need for measles vaccination

14 Feb 2018 Hits:138 Be the first to comment!

The City Health Office (CHO) yesterday appealed to parents to submit their children for measles vaccination. This after a seven-month baby died last February 6, 2018 allegedly due to measles, five [...] Read more


11 Jan 2018 Hits:280 Be the first to comment!

Este el Istoria del Jong Cariaga Mindanao Cup 2018 que ya hace na Golden Boys gym anoche. Ya sale Champion el Myeisha Jolo kay completo todo departamento del juego especialmente [...] Read more

BFP personnel to undergo fire suppression activities

10 Jan 2018 Hits:235 Be the first to comment!

Personnel of the Bureau of Fire Protection in Zamboanga City will undergo fire suppression trainings in the days to come in a bid to keep them abreast of the firefighting [...] Read more


10 Jan 2018 Hits:222 Be the first to comment!

Del Domingo pasao ya mira kita con el Resto Del Mundo FC contra Red Corals United donde ya sale Tabla el juego na Soccer Football. Amo quel el ultimo juego [...] Read more

TFZ gets 10 motorcycles from City Government

09 Jan 2018 Hits:257 Be the first to comment!

Task Force Zamboanga (TFZ) on Monday received from the local government 10 units of XRM motorcycles for security patrols in the outskirts of the city. Mayor Beng Climaco together with Councilor [...] Read more

Beng leads destruction of seized items

09 Jan 2018 Hits:283 Be the first to comment!

To show the Local Government’s firm commitment to public safety and security, Mayor Beng Climaco on Monday personally maneuvered a road roller and led the destruction of seized items such [...] Read more

Warring clans arm cache seized by gov't troops in Lanao del Sur

09 Jan 2018 Hits:302 Be the first to comment!

The military on Saturday seized a cached of high-powered firearms from warring clans, following a clearing operation in Lanao del Sur province. Capt. Jo-Ann Petinglay, spokesperson of the Western Mindanao Command, [...] Read more


09 Jan 2018 Hits:247 Be the first to comment!

MINDANAO LEAGUE 2018 BY JONG CARIAGA: Boalan Agm  nuevo star athlete Kaiwa Sabdulla y si Neil Jumao-as ya dale mira kay puede sila gana con el maga mapuersa team como el [...] Read more


08 Jan 2018 Hits:184 Be the first to comment!

JONG CARIAGA BASKETBALL MINDANAO CUP ‘18. Que el juego ta ase na golden boys gym ta principia 7:00 del noche. Fritz Vesagas amo el ya ase gana con el disuyu [...] Read more


07 Jan 2018 Hits:219 Be the first to comment!

JONG CARIAGA MINDANAO CUP Este el un torneo que debe kita mira kay el team del Myiesha Jolo tiene 5 ex PBA athleta y el losdemas puru mga star players de [...] Read more

Climaco reiterates appeal to Customs: Stop smuggling

06 Jan 2018 Hits:800 Be the first to comment!

Mayor Beng Climaco has once again appealed to the Bureau of Customs to clean up Zamboanga City against smuggling, and it can only be done if the agency will deputize [...] Read more

Escapee recaptured in Isabela

06 Jan 2018 Hits:236 Be the first to comment!

An inmate who escaped last Tuesday night from his cell in Isbela City was recaptured by the Isabela City Police on Wednesday afternoon in one of the islands in Maluso, [...] Read more

Beng orders intensified drive vs illegal quarrying

06 Jan 2018 Hits:215 Be the first to comment!

Mayor Beng Climaco has ordered a renewed campaign against illegal quarrying activities as she cited the city’s firm advocacy on environmental protection. Mayor Climaco Thursday has directed City Police Director PSSupt. [...] Read more

Four hurt in motorcycle collision

06 Jan 2018 Hits:227 Be the first to comment!

Four people were injured when two motorcycles accidentally collided in Zone 3, Barangay Guisao, Zamboanga City, on Thursday. Injured were Ryan Pantaleon y Atilano, 27, single, driver of the XRM motorcycle [...] Read more

Old man, old woman found dead in different barangays

05 Jan 2018 Hits:225 Be the first to comment!

Two elders were found dead inside their house in two separate places in Sitio Parkas, Barangay Boalan and Zone 2, Barangay Lumbangan, both in this city last Wednesday. Reports showed that [...] Read more


05 Jan 2018 Hits:189 Be the first to comment!

Este si Bryan Ray Mangaser Siglos, su palayao “Bry”, 17 años de edad, anak di Severino Ledesma Siglos y Maria Ruzen Ramos Mangaser. Su hermano si Bennett Jhordany hermana si [...] Read more

CDRRMC okeys P3M cash aid for Vinta-stricken towns

04 Jan 2018 Hits:289 Be the first to comment!

The City Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (CDRRMC) has approved a resolution recommending the allocation of some P3 million from the city’s quick response fund, for financial assistance to [...] Read more