My Google Page Rank

House prosecution panel replies to impeachment raps vs SC chief justice


The impeachment prosecution panel of the House of Representatives on Monday filed its reply to the Senate who sits as the impeachment court, to Supreme Court (SC) Chief Justice Renato Corona’s answer to the impeachment complaint.

Chief prosecutor Iloilo Rep. Niel Tupas said their reply "entirely debunks all of the defenses raised by Chief Justice Corona in his answer (dated Dec. 21, 2011)."

With the submission of their reply, Tupas said they were more confident that the Senate would be convinced of the strength of the case against the chief justice.

The 38-page Reply sought for the immediate denial of Corona’s prayer for the dismissal of the complaint; that the trial proceed immediately; and to convict the Chief Justice for betrayal of public trust.

Among the salient points raised was that the impeachment "is not an attack on the Judiciary and does not seek to threaten its independence."

On the contrary, it said the impeachment "aims to restore the independence of the Judiciary by freeing it from the clutches of influence of GMA (Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo), former FG (First Gentleman) Mike Arroyo and their cabal. It will not weaken the judiciary but strengthen it. What the impeachment seeks to do is to restore the people’s faith of the independence of the SC which was sorely lost with the string of decisions made by CJ Corona to protect GMA. Most significant was the issuance of an ex parte TRO (temporary restraining order) that would have allowed GMA to go scot-free."

It further said that the impeachment did not violate the Rule of Law.

In fact, it said the complaint "seeks to strengthen it by showing to the people that, contrary to Corona’s contention, any person, even a Chief Justice is not above the law. When a public officer betrays the public trust, he must be brought to justice and held accountable, even if it’s the Chief Justice that is accused. Only then will people believe that there really is the rule of law in our country."

The congressmen-prosecutors also said in their reply that there was no factual basis on Corona’s claim that President Benigno Aquino III wanted to appoint his own Chief Justice, which will be at his beck and call.

"Firstly, this argument only betrays his (Corona) deepest secret: that he is beholden to the person who appointed him -- GMA. Secondly, if that were the objective of PNoy, it should be noted that the three appointees of PNoy voted against the Hacienda Luisita issue. This completely belies Corona’s contention," it said.

They also said that non-disclosure of its statement of assets and liabilities networth (SALN) was a blatant disregard by the Chief Justice on the policy of transparency, public accountability, and the public’s constitutional right to information.

"Section 17, Article XI of 1987 Constitution requires all public officers and employees to file and make available their SALN for inspection and copying by the public. The law makes no exception. For Corona to shield himself from this constitutional measure on transparency using an internal Supreme Court guideline, smacks of a blatant violation of clear requirements stated by law," they said.

"The Chief Justice should not hide behind technicalities. The people want the truth to come out. He has been saying that he has a powerhouse team and that he has been eagerly waiting to present his evidence. The prosecution is likewise ready. Let's get it on for the sake of the people," said Tupas.

Meanwhile, the Iloilo solon said the last slot of the 11-man prosecution panel will be occupied by a lady prosecutor.

"We will not disclose the congresswoman's identity at the moment until her election is made on the plenary floor on Jan. 16," he said.

On the other hand, House Deputy Speaker and Quezon Rep. Lorenzo "Erin" Tanada III withdrew from the prosecution panel to be part of the pool of speakers.

Tanada will join Reps. Federico Miro Quimbo (Marikina) and Juan Edgardo Angara (Aurora), who were earlier tapped to be the deputy spokespersons of the panel.

His slot in the prosecution panel will be taken by alternate prosecutor Cibac party-list Rep. Sherwin Tugna.

Tanada expressed confidence the prosecution team will get the 16 votes needed to impeach the Chief Justice.

By Lilybeth G. Ison

Related news items:
Newer news items:
Older news items:

Add comment

Security code


16 Nov 2018 Hits:51 Be the first to comment!

For the Tetuan Parish, that very common expression means literally just that, for on Friday, November 16, 2018, at 7 in the evening at the Centro Pastoral, the concert UN NOCHE DE OFRECIMIENTO, will wow its audience. The four-part concert aims to raise the roof with the rarely seen Broadway caliber talents of our singing and dancing priests. The first segment is the Filipiniana where the musical score is proudly Original Filipino Music of Ryan Cayabyab and regional favorites in Chavacano, Visayan and Tagalog. It is followed by religious renditions in part two like: Lay Up Your Treasures in Heaven, What A Friend and Amazing Grace. The 3rd part is, of course, Broadway with mega hits like Tonight from the West Side Story, Bridge [...] Read more

Prev Next Page:

Man stabbed in Rio Hondo

16 Nov 2018 Hits:71 Be the first to comment!

A bakery worker was stabbed and wounded by his co-worker in Sitio Hongkong, Barangay Rio Hondo, Zamboanga City on Wednesday night. Police Officer 3 Had-Anuar Edding, investigator-on-case, of Police Station 11 [...] Read more

Three nabbed for illegal drugs

16 Nov 2018 Hits:90 Be the first to comment!

Three persons were arrested when operatives of Police Station 9 seized from them 13 sachets of suspected shabu during a buy-bust operation at Barangay Recodo, Zamboanga City on Thursday dawn. Arrested [...] Read more

DOH 9 conducts training on GI, community-based treatment for PWUDs

15 Nov 2018 Hits:113 Be the first to comment!

The Department of Health Region IX (DOH 9) conducted the Training on General Intervention (GI) and Community-based Treatment Care Services for Person Who Use Drugs (PWUDs) from November 13-15, 2018. With [...] Read more

DENR-EMB 9 conducts SWM plan finalization of ZamPen LGUs

14 Nov 2018 Hits:135 Be the first to comment!

The Department of Environment and Natural Resources-Environmental Management Bureau (DENR-EMB) Region IX is conducting a 10-year Solid Waste Management (SWM) plan update and finalization of 33 local government units (LGUs) [...] Read more

Man accused of child abuse, arrested

13 Nov 2018 Hits:176 Be the first to comment!

Two teenagers filed a complaint for child abuse against a 55-year-old man at Police Station 7 last Sunday. Ellyn, married, a resident of Barangay Pasonanca, Zamboanga City, averred to the police [...] Read more

Brgy Chair nabs pedicab driver carrying shabu

13 Nov 2018 Hits:122 Be the first to comment!

A delivery boy was arrested in a buy-bust operation conducted by elements of Police Station 4 led by Chief Insp. Hazel Fernandez at Barangay Baliwasan, Zamboanga City  on Sunday. Police identified [...] Read more

Navforwem honors fleet-marine troops for rescue of KV Duterte

13 Nov 2018 Hits:194 Be the first to comment!

The Naval Forces Western Mindanao (Navforwem) has honored sailors, marines, Fleet-Marine personnel and navies for the successful rescue of kidnapped victim (KV) Jose Duterte and exceptional feats in the accomplishment [...] Read more

Police searching for armed man for mauling

12 Nov 2018 Hits:133 Be the first to comment!

A resident of Barangay Mampang, Zamboanga City, is now being hunted by personnel of Police Station 6 for mauling and totting his gun at another person on Sunday. Police report shows [...] Read more

Team Climaco condemns misinformation, fake news

09 Nov 2018 Hits:343 Be the first to comment!

Members of the Team Climaco have strongly criticized and condemned misinformation drive allegedly hatched by their political foes and propagandists, who are desperate to destroy the many and outstanding accomplishments [...] Read more

Man hacked by father-in-law

09 Nov 2018 Hits:147 Be the first to comment!

A man was hacked and wounded by his father-in-law at Sibiktol Drive, Barangay Arena Blanco, Zamboanga City, on Wednesday. The victim was identified as Jarrin Jalmaani y Gadong, married and a [...] Read more

More Filipinos to be engaged in HIV-AIDS awareness drive

08 Nov 2018 Hits:191 Be the first to comment!

The right information on HIV-AIDS will curb the spread of this disease. But putting information out there isn’t enough, a senior government official believes. There has to be constant engagement [...] Read more

CHO: Fear of Dengvaxia prevents children from getting vaccines

07 Nov 2018 Hits:257 Be the first to comment!

Assistant City Health Officer Dr. Kibtiya Uddin reported that the fear of Dengvaxia vaccine has prevented children from getting other types of vaccines during City Hall's weekly press conference on [...] Read more

Army officer, 3 soldiers injured in clash with Abu Sayyaf in Sulu

07 Nov 2018 Hits:302 Be the first to comment!

An Army officer and three more soldiers were wounded in an encounter with Abu Sayyaf terrorists in Sulu province on Monday afternoon. Lt. Col. Gerry Besana,  spokesperson of Western Mindanao Command [...] Read more

Beng distributes relief goods to Triplet fire victims

18 Oct 2018 Hits:254 Be the first to comment!

Mayor Beng Climaco on Wednesday afternoon spearheaded the distribution of relief goods to families displaced by the early dawn fire in Lemon Drive, Triplet, Barangay Canelar. Mayor Climaco, assisted by personnel [...] Read more

DTI reports slight hike in prices of basic goods

18 Oct 2018 Hits:232 Be the first to comment!

Following its continuing monitoring of prices of all consumable goods in the local markets, the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) has reported a slight increase in the prices of [...] Read more

OCENR preps SWM in barangays, basura run

18 Oct 2018 Hits:211 Be the first to comment!

The Office of the City Environment and Natural Resources (OCENR) is working to strengthen the capacities of local barangays in line with sanitation, particularly solid waste management. Public Services Officer IV [...] Read more

Mayor Beng files candidacy, vows to continue pro-poor programs

17 Oct 2018 Hits:272 Be the first to comment!

In an expected sea of supporters to join her today, popular Mayor Maria Isabelle “Beng” Climaco is scheduled to file her certificate of candidacy for re-election this morning at the [...] Read more

Team Colorao to file COC today

17 Oct 2018 Hits:204 Be the first to comment!

The “Team Colorao” alliance will be filing their official Certificates of Candidacy (COC) early morning today, October 17, 2018. The powerhouse four party alliance will be led by party standard bearer, [...] Read more