My Google Page Rank

SC junks gov't plea on ill-gotten wealth raps vs. Marcos


The Supreme Court (SC) has upheld a decision of the Sandiganbayan dismissing the Philippine government's motion to admit supplemental offer of evidence in a civil case it filed against former President Ferdinand Marcos and several others for alleged ill-gotten wealth, which was bestowed to other corporations.

This was after the SC en banc denied the motion for reconsideration (MR) of the government since the issues raised therein were mere rehashed arguments.

In a two-page resolution dated March 13, 2012 and signed by SC en banc Clerk of Court Atty. Enriqueta Vidal, the SC maintained its 7-7 decision and junked the government's appeal for lack of merit.

"After considering the arguments raised in the motion for reconsideration (of the Court's December 13, 2011 Decision) filed by the Republic of the Philippines (petitioner), the Court resolves to deny the same for lack of merit," the decision said.

The SC said that "as stated in the last part of the December 13, 2011 Decision, as early as December 6, 2011 the en banc already deliberated on the case and failed to arrive at a conclusive decision because of a tie vote, which resulted in the re-voting on December 13, 2011 with same results. Since the Court remained equally divided after the re-voting, the December 13, 2011 Decision of the Court prevails."

The SC also dismissed the government's request for Chief Justice Renato Corona to voluntarily inhibit from participating in the case in view of his pending impeachment trial at the Senate.

"The Court also resolves to deny the petitioner's additional prayer that the Chief Justice voluntarily recuse himself from participating in the case. The Chief Justice had already weighed the merits of the case and voted on the main decision even before he was hastily impeached on December 12, 2011," it said.

It can be recalled that with a vote of 7-7, with one Justice taking no part, the SC en banc dismissed the petition for lack of merit filed by the Republic of the Philippines, through the Presidential Commission on Good Government (PCGG).
The SC upheld the Feb. 7, 2002 resolution of the Sandiganbayan.

The half of the winning justices were Corona; Associate Justices Arturo Brion; Diosdado Peralta; Lucas Bersamin; Mariano del Castillo; Jose Perez; and Jose Mendoza.
Those who maintained their dissents were Associate Justices Antonio Carpio; Presbitero Velasco, Jr.; Roberto Abad; Martin Villarama, Jr.; Maria Lourdes Aranal-Sereno; Bienvenido Reyes; and Estela Perlas-Bernabe while Teresita Leonardo-De Castro maintained her inhibition since the case originated from the Sandiganbayan, wherein she was a former member.

The PCGG filed a complaint on July 22, 1987 against Jose Africa; Manuel Nieto, Jr.; Ferdinand Marcos; Imelda Marcos; Ferdinand Marcos, Jr.; Juan Ponce Enrile; and Potenciano Ilusorio for reconveyance, reversion, accounting, restitution, and damages before the Sandiganbayan.
It alleged that the respondents illegally manipulated the purchase of the major shareholdings of Cable and Wireless Limited in Eastern Telecommunications Philippines, Inc. (ETPI), which shareholdings respondents Africa and Nieto, Jr. held for themselves and, through their holdings and the corporations they organized, beneficially for respondents Ferdinand and Imelda.

In the Aug. 7, 1991 PCGG-conducted ETPI stockholders meeting, a PCGG-controlled board of directors was elected.
Later, the registered ETPI stockholders convened a special stockholders meeting wherein another set of board of directors was elected.
As a result, two sets of ETPI board and officers were elected.

Africa, as an ETPI stockholder, filed a petition for certiorari, with prayer for a temporary restraining order/preliminary injunction with the Sandiganbayan seeking to nullify the Aug. 5, 1991 and Aug. 9, 1991 orders of the PCGG.

These orders directed Africa to account for his sequestered shares in ETPI and to cease and desist from exercising voting rights on the sequestered shares in the special stockholders' meeting to be held on Aug. 12, 1991, from representing himself as a director, officer, employee or agent of ETPI, and from participating, directly or indirectly in the management of ETPI.

During the pendency of Africa's petition, he filed a motion with the Sandiganbayan, alleging that since Jan. 29, 1988 the PCGG had been "illegally 'exercising' the rights of stockholders of ETPI," especially in the election of the members of the board of directors.
Africa prayed for the issuance of an order for the "calling and holding of (ETPI) annual stockholders' meeting for 1992 under the [c]ourt's control and supervision and prescribed guidelines."

The PCGG assailed this resolution before the SC via a petition for certiorari imputing grave abuse of discretion on the Sandiganbayan for holding, inter alia, that the registered stockholders of ETPI had the right to vote.

It filed its third motion on Nov. 16, 2001 seeking once more the admission of the bane deposition (Deposition of Maurice Bane).
However, it was denied by the Sandiganbayan, which prompted the PCGG to seek redress with the SC, citing grave abuse of discretion on the part of the anti-graft court.
In its decision, the SC said that "the issue before us does not involve the applicability of the rule on mandatory taking of judicial notice; neither is the applicability of the rule on discretionary taking of judicial notice seriously pursued."

"Rather, the petitioner approaches the concept of judicial notice from a genealogical perspective of treating whatever evidence offered in any of the children cases -- Civil Case 0130 -- as evidence in the parent case…or of the whole family of cases," the SC said.
The SC added that "to the petitioner, the supposed relationship of these cases warrants the taking of judicial notice."

"It is the duty of the petitioner, as a party-litigant, to properly lay before the court the evidence it relies upon in support of the relief it seeks, instead of imposing that same duty on the court. We invite the petitioner's attention to our prefatory pronouncement in Lopez v. Sandiganbayan:
"Down the oft-trodden path in our judicial system, by common sense, tradition and the law, the Judge in trying a case sees only with judicial eyes as he ought to know nothing about the facts of the case, except those which have been adduced judicially in evidence. Thus, when the case is up for trial, the judicial head is empty as to facts involved and it is incumbent upon the litigants to the action to establish by evidence the facts upon which they rely."

"We therefore refuse, in the strongest terms, to entertain the petitioner's argument that we should take judicial notice of the Bane deposition," the SC ruling said.

by: PNA

Related news items:
Newer news items:
Older news items:

Add comment

Security code

Summer sport program set for May

29 Mar 2017 Hits:57 Be the first to comment!

Some 26 sport disciplines will be offered in the month-long summer sports program to be spearheaded by the local government this May. The Basic Sports Summer Camp 2017, most commonly known as the Learn to Play a Sport Program, is a training and sports clinic which aims to teach children ages 8 to 15 the rudiments of their chosen sport discipline for free. Now on its 22nd year, the summer Learn to Play is part of the local government’s sports development program. Aside from providing a fun and recreational learning experience during their summer break, the month-long program also serves as a training ground to scout and hone future athletes of the City. This year’s summer Learn to Play will include: archery, arnis, [...] Read more

Prev Next Page:

Summer activities lined up for Sta. Cruz isle

29 Mar 2017 Hits:33 Be the first to comment!

The city government through its Protected Area Management Unit (PAMU) has lined up several activities for the enjoyment of the flux of visitors who are expected to troop to Sta. [...] Read more

Businesswoman, companion robbed

29 Mar 2017 Hits:32 Be the first to comment!

A businesswoman and her companion were allegedly robbed at gunpoint by three unidentified armed suspects along Don Alfaro Street, Barangay Tetuan, this city, Monday night. The victims were identified as Darwisa [...] Read more

SS Chair delivers keynote message during 16th National Convention of Lawyers

29 Mar 2017 Hits:35 Be the first to comment!

Social Security Commission Chairman (SSC) Dean Amado D. Valdez (top photo) stressed the importance of paradigm shift to provide SSS with greater income opportunities which will also translate to the [...] Read more

Globe lands SEA-US cable system in Davao City; nears commercial operations

28 Mar 2017 Hits:62 Be the first to comment!

Globe Telecom successfully landed over the weekend the Southeast Asia-United States (SEA-US) submarine cable system, bringing the company one step closer towards the provision of richer and enhanced international connectivity [...] Read more

Metro Manila residents feel safer; cops step up crime drive

28 Mar 2017 Hits:50 Be the first to comment!

At least 82 percent of Metro Manila residents feel safer in the streets due to the intensified police campaign against illegal drugs, a Pulse Asia survey shows. Pulse Asia randomly selected [...] Read more

SSS eyes mandatory OFW coverage

28 Mar 2017 Hits:50 Be the first to comment!

The state-run Social Security System said it is asking the help of lawmakers to implement the mandatory coverage of Overseas Filipino Workers (OFWs) following its goal to expand its members’ [...] Read more

Students under SPES to help direct traffic flow - Jawo

28 Mar 2017 Hits:61 Be the first to comment!

The city government will use the services of students under the Special Program for Employment of Students (SPES) to help in the implementation of the experimental traffic rerouting scheme. Traffic coordinator [...] Read more

(For effective traffic scheme:) Illegal parking not tolerated

28 Mar 2017 Hits:60 Be the first to comment!

Authorities warned motorists anew against illegal parking, particularly in light of the experimental traffic scheme currently being implemented. Executive Assistant Jawo Jimenez said owners of illegally parked vehicles will immediately receive [...] Read more

(TFZ change of command set today:) Beng cites Uy for efforts vs terrorism

28 Mar 2017 Hits:59 Be the first to comment!

Mayor Beng Climaco has cited Col. Juvymax Uy, outgoing commander of Task Force Zamboanga for his hardwork and efforts in maintaining peace and security in the city that resulted to [...] Read more

LIAC on transportation tackles traffic scheme, truck ban

25 Mar 2017 Hits:155 Be the first to comment!

The City Administrator’s Office on Thursday afternoon convened the Local Inter-Agency Committee (LIAC) on the Enforcement of Land Transportation Regulations to tackle pressing issues affecting traffic in the city’s main [...] Read more

Visually-impaired Dapilin graduates cum laude

25 Mar 2017 Hits:92 Be the first to comment!

A visually-impaired student from Basilan Province is graduating cum laude with a degree of Bachelor of Science in Education at the Western Mindanao State University (WMSU) on Wednesday, March 29. Abdulazis [...] Read more

Chides Magdalo men for being ‘cowards’

24 Mar 2017 Hits:122 Be the first to comment!

President Rodrigo Duterte on Monday branded Vice President Leni Robredo as an enemy who was in a hurry to claim the presidency and described Senator Antonio Trillanes IV as “a [...] Read more

Globe equips Manila Science HS with 21st Century classroom

24 Mar 2017 Hits:96 Be the first to comment!

Globe Telecom and Habitat for Humanity officially turned over to Manila Science High School (MaSci) over the weekend a multifunctional Information and Communications Technology (ICT) laboratory with a collaborative working [...] Read more

WestMinCom troops honor fallen marine soldier

24 Mar 2017 Hits:100 Be the first to comment!

A fallen soldier from the Marine Battalion Landing Team (MBLT)-2, who was killed during a clash with communist rebels, was honored in a send-off ceremony before he was brought to [...] Read more

Six alleged drug pushers arrested

24 Mar 2017 Hits:97 Be the first to comment!

Six persons, including a minor, were arrested in a series of buy-bust operations conducted by the different police stations of the Zamboanga City Police Office (ZCPO), Wednesday. The Drug Enforcement Team [...] Read more

MGB-9 orders stoppage of illegal gold mining in Baliguian town

23 Mar 2017 Hits:94 Be the first to comment!

Local small-scale miners looking for gold ores were ordered to stop illegal mining activities in Pigbogololan area in the rural town of Baliguian, Zamboanga del Norte early this month after [...] Read more

Globe myBusiness gives tips to working in the comfort of your own home

23 Mar 2017 Hits:95 Be the first to comment!

Many business owners enjoy working from home, but there’s a challenge that automatically comes with it.  There are certainly many perks, like being in charge of your own time, dressing [...] Read more

Cocolisap funds await PCA, City Hall coordination gab

22 Mar 2017 Hits:88 Be the first to comment!

Funds to rehabilitate the coconut industry following the cocolisap devastation cannot be released as of yet until after the Philippine Coconut Authority (PCA) regional office 9 and the city government [...] Read more