My Google Page Rank

BIR loses in P600-M tax case vs Petron

PDFPrintE-mail

BAGUIO CITY - The Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) has lost a P600-million tax case against multinational oil company Petron Corp. (Petron).
In a ruling promulgated on March 21, 2012 but was released to the media on Tuesday, the SC, through Associate Justice Maria Lourdes Sereno, dismissed the appeal filed by the BIR for lack of merit.

The BIR elevated the case to the SC after the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) en banc reversed its Second Division ruling ordering Petron to pay P600,769,353.95 as deficiency excise taxes for 1995 to 1998, including surcharges and interest plus 25 percent surcharge and 20 percent delinquency interest per annum.

In its petition, the BIR said that Tax Credit Certificates (TCCs) from various Board of Investments (BOI) entities assigned to Petron covering taxable years 1995 to 1998, which Petron used in the payment of its excise taxes, had been cancelled by the Department of Finance (DOF) pursuant to DOF EXCOM Resolution No. 03-05-99 for having been "fraudulently issued and transferred."

In its 2007 decision, the CTA Second Division directed Petron to pay BIR P600,769,353 in deficiency excise taxes for subject years.
However, the CTA en banc said that Petron was a "transferee in good faith," had no participation in the issuance and transfer of the TCCs, and could not be held accountable for the cancelled TCCs.

In its decision, the SC echoed the CTA en banc's ruling that Petron is a "transferee in good faith and for value of the subject TCCs."
"From the records, we observe that the BIR had no allegation that there was a deviation from the process for the approval of the TCCs, which Petron used as payment to settle its excise tax liabilities for the years 1995 to 1998," the SC said.

"We agree with the pronouncement of CTA en banc that Petron has not been shown or proven to have participated in the alleged fraudulent acts involved in the transfer and utilization of the subject TCCs. Petron had the right to rely on the joint stipulation that absolved it from any participation in the alleged fraud pertaining to the issuance and procurement of the subject TCCs," it said.

"The joint stipulation made by the parties consequently obviated the opportunity of the BIR to present evidence on this matter as no proof is required for an admission made by a party in the course of the proceedings. Thus, the BIR cannot now be allowed to change its stand and renege on that admission," the SC said.

by: PNA




Related news items:
Newer news items:
Older news items:

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

One gun-for-hire dead in shootout with cops

24 Nov 2017 Hits:105 Be the first to comment!

An alleged member of a gun-for-hire group was killed in a shootout with personnel of the Regional Public Safety Battalion 9 (RPSB9) in Barangay Balok, Sindangan Municipality, Zamboanga del Norte (ZDN) Province on Tuesday. Police Regional Office 9 (RPO9) spokesperson Chief Insp. Helen Galvez identified the fatality as Rene Carcillas, 49, married, of Barangay Diquis, Manukan Municipality, ZDN. The suspect was rushed to Sindagan Municipal Hospital for medical treatment but the attending physician declared him dead on arrival. Galvez told Zamboanga Today that a checkpoint was established in the said area on Tuesday night by combined personnel of the RPSB9 and Sindangan Municipal Police Station. The authorities flagged down a color black and white Honda XRM motorcycle approaching the checkpoint but the back-rider suddenly [...] Read more

Prev Next Page:

FERNDALE SCHOOL 2017 SBP PASSERELLE MINDANAO CHAMPION

24 Nov 2017 Hits:52 Be the first to comment!

Este el istoria del Ferndale International School locao na Veterans Avenue, Ciudad de Zamboanga. El presidente del escuela si Dr. Anicia A. Alvarez y el official ta ayuda mira canamon [...] Read more


BAP TOURNAMENT AND OFFICIATING LEAGUE

23 Nov 2017 Hits:68 Be the first to comment!

Schedule games for Nov. 26,2017 (Sun) Golden Boys Gym 8:30 am  Bonchon -vs-  J Vince 10:00 am  Jocsie     -vs-   RRJ RESULT of the games played last Nov.19,2017(Sun) WEST SCC GYM.. SAN JOSE [...] Read more


Four houses destroyed by fire

23 Nov 2017 Hits:73 Be the first to comment!

Four houses made-of-light materials were totally razed to the ground in Royal Lane Drive, Barangay Tugbungan. Zamboanga City Central Fire Station (ZCCFS), District Fire Marshall Clint Cha identified the owners of [...] Read more


WMSU, WMBA host National Training on Bio-Threat Reduction for LGUs

22 Nov 2017 Hits:78 Be the first to comment!

The Western Mindanao State University (WMSU), through the Western Mindanao Biosafety and Biosecurity Association (WMBA), and in partnership with the United States Department of Defense- Defense Threat Reduction Agency, successfully [...] Read more


Fire Chief prepares for fire

22 Nov 2017 Hits:81 Be the first to comment!

In preparation for the coming Yuletide Season, District Fire Marshal, Chief Insp. Clint Cha has called on all fire sub-stations to prepare and ready their various equipment and firetrucks. Cha said [...] Read more


DOH cites importance EO 28

22 Nov 2017 Hits:67 Be the first to comment!

The Department of Health, Regional Office 9 yesterday explained the objective and importance of Executive Order Number 28 of President Rodrigo Duterte on June 27, 2017, providing for the regulation [...] Read more


Wesmincom Chief says ASG strenght significantly dropped

22 Nov 2017 Hits:74 Be the first to comment!

Lt. Gen. Carlito Galvez, Western Mindanao Command Chief, yesterday said that the strength of the Abu Sayyaf Group in Sulu, Basilan and Tawi Tawi has significantly decreased. Galvez said this is [...] Read more


D' CUSTODIAN BALLER … NELLIE

22 Nov 2017 Hits:64 Be the first to comment!

Este si Marnelli Candido Berba, su palayao “Nellie”, 33 años de edad, 5’0” el altor, residente de Talon Talon, Ciudad de Zamboanga. Su mayores si Ernesto N. Berba y Maridol [...] Read more


380 aspiring fire officers take qualifying exams

21 Nov 2017 Hits:80 Be the first to comment!

More or less 380 applicants took the qualifying exam conducted by the Bureau of Fire Protection (BFP-IX) at the Zamboanga State College of Marine Sciences and Technology, yesterday. District Fire Marshal, [...] Read more


Cops, probers undergo training on drug cases

21 Nov 2017 Hits:72 Be the first to comment!

Members of the local police, investigators and other law enforcement agencies undergo a two-day enhancement training on handling drug cases in a bid to ensure successful implementation of the war [...] Read more


Submarine cable landing stations to speed-up internet connectivity – DOST

21 Nov 2017 Hits:117 Be the first to comment!

The slow internet connection in the country may soon be a thing of the past. This was according to the Department of Science and Technology (DOST) as it welcomed the [...] Read more


LADY PANTHER WRESTLER… ERICA

20 Nov 2017 Hits:80 Be the first to comment!

Este si Erica Bataclan Martinez, su palayao “Ecang”, 17 años , 5’3” el altor,    Su mayores si Oscar B. Martinez y Lariza A. Bataclan Martinez, su hermano y hermana [...] Read more


FOOTBALL CHIEF… TENG

19 Nov 2017 Hits:76 Be the first to comment!

Este si VICENTE EDUARDO S. TORRES, ta llama conele “Teng/Pardz/Boboy”, 62 años de edad , casao y su esposa si Esther Facultad Torres Y diila anak si Pompeyo F. Torres [...] Read more


AboitizPower sustains strong foothold in hydropower business

18 Nov 2017 Hits:138 Be the first to comment!

On the back of a strong demand for renewable energy (RE), AboitizPower continues to ramp up its portfolio of generation facilities across the Philippines. AboitizPower's subsidiary, SN AboitizPower, has completed the [...] Read more


ZAMBOANGA FOOTBALL - ROLL D BALL

18 Nov 2017 Hits:86 Be the first to comment!

Del Nov. 12, 2017 Domingo el Segundo semana de Season long Zamboanga Football league. El primer juego tan feature cun Resto del Mundo contra  Zamboanga United . Ta pricura man [...] Read more


Police shift war on drugs to anti-gun-for-hire drive

17 Nov 2017 Hits:99 Be the first to comment!

Police regional director and vice chair of the Regional Peace and Order Council (RPOC) for Western Mindanao Chief Supt. Billy Beltran announced recently that all police operatives previously assigned in [...] Read more


Military launch rescue ops for latest victims of ASG

17 Nov 2017 Hits:137 Be the first to comment!

Government troops are now conducting operations to rescue the six people, including two children, who have been abducted by about 15 suspected Abu Sayyaf bandits in Patikul, Sulu, according to [...] Read more


OCENR sets city-wide clean up on Nov 25

17 Nov 2017 Hits:80 Be the first to comment!

The City Government through the Office of the City Environment and Natural Resources (OCENR) will head a city-wide clean up drive on November 25. “We are going to have a city-wide [...] Read more